Showing posts with label a case. Show all posts
Showing posts with label a case. Show all posts

a case against legalising ball tampering...

shared by straight point on Saturday, February 13, 2010

it seems now that shahid afridi did some service to cricket when he bite the ball... though his method was audacious at best but it has certainly opened the pandora box of debates for pros and cons...

fellow blogger and renowned cricket writer samir chopra presents the well considered case for legalising ball tampering... though like him i too do not agree with the morality issue... but legalising ball tampering does has its down side too...

there can be no clear cut measures on how much is too much... and even on that there will be different interpretations by different individuals that will only lead to more chaos with teams feeling hard done by the judgments... against clear cut measures as of now... if you are caught, you are punished which has been accepted by all though certain stuart broad will be an exception but still...

you do not have to go too far but to see the udrs system's fate... no team is happy with it and wherever it has been implemented has created more resentment with the questionable interpretations and judgments from talents like harpers...

the eradication of obvious decisions for which it was conceived can easily be carried out by third umpires... like in the case of raina in one day international recently when third umpire helped in over turning the decision given by simon taufel without the referral system in place... but you bet bureaucrats to come up with more complicated system than actually needed to make their presence felt...

the most compelling arguments given by those who are favoring ball tampering are that since the pitches are becoming roads... the batsmen using mongoose bats without worrying much about lateral movements... boundaries getting shortened where even miss hits clears the rope by good distance... game is decisively getting one dimensional... in favor of batsman... so bowlers need some assistance too to make it even...

but by this account can we legalise shop lifting in a recession time when finding jobs becomes more difficult... can we use unemployment as valid justification for it...?

ok... the example may not be that good but you get the drift...

rather than legalising ball tampering and inviting implementation and procedural headaches associated with it... it is far easier to arm bowlers with some allowances like lifting one bouncer per over rule... doing away with front foot no ball... bit liberal lbw parameters but more importantly giving them pitches which bring some smile back on their faces where they relish the challenge of bowling for five days...

as aakash chopra's latest article suggests... ball tampering is an art... and how a certain player took the bet to do it while talking to an umpire... i sincerely believe that legalising it will only kill this art...

those who can fool on field umpires and more importantly dissecting eyes of dozens of on field cameras placed strategically all over the ground... i have only one thing to say to them...

take a bow guys!!

click to translate »

a case for rohit sharma...

shared by straight point on Tuesday, February 17, 2009

competition hotting up the cap...


of late we have been hearing so much about rohit that sometimes i feel he has really made it…

some feel (including your truly) that he has not lived upto his potential…some feel that he should not be in team at all…

though his numbers are erratic, no doubt about it, but sometimes one has to see beyond numbers to see the real worth of a player…

he has good technique...has good array of strokes…plays with straight bat more than any other player in the team…though looks bit lazy at times but his strokes do pack some punch…

» recommended link:
hayden's farewell &
thou shalt be proven wrong @ BCC!
for me he should be permanent no.3 player in the ODI team and should not be fiddled around in line up so much…in any case we have many players who are aggressive to overtly aggressive…we need a player who has sound technique...can hold on to innings specially in conditions other than subcontinent…

no wonder he had reasonably good tour down under where he impressed many with his straight play…the extra bit of time he seem to have in his hand to play strokes...ability to find gaps with relative ease etc etc…all in all the hallmark of a good player who has potential to become even better with some more experience…

so what’s stopping him then…?

he too is responsible for cutting his innings short with wrong shot selections…seems to put on some extra flab around his waist…a definite sign indicating that early fame seems to have stuck him…which can divert the focus from game a bit…which has made him what he is today…

but we must show some patience with him...he really is good potential in our hand…and should not be discarded in jiffy…i am sure that garry kirsten and upton must have spotted this by now…will definitely be working with him to sort out issues and his focus towards game...timely guidance under watchful eyes can/will do a world of good to him...

to me…he is definitely a player worth investing…and i am not even a mumbaiker... :)

click to translate »

A case for Kaif...

shared by straight point on Wednesday, February 06, 2008

while i was visiting my friend soulberry's latest post on Duleep Trophy Experiment...

it got me going to don the devil's cap again...

...and this time its for Kaif...

does this name ring a bell to you??

...yes...the same forgotten man of indian cricket...the best captain india will never have...the player who is still carrying the scars of being labeled as failure...

i wanted to put it earlier but somehow kept it on hold...but soublerry's mention in his post and topicality of the issue made me come up with post...

topical did i said?

if you saw yesterday's between india and srilanka match live there was discussion going on...between i guess harsha and gavaskar... regarding labeling the failures...that system should also keep discarded players like him in radar coz they have got valuable experience and know what to expect in different conditions and certainly are not that old...and then Kaifs name came up...

i found myself nodding to what they were discussing and needless to say agree with them...

kaif have not done that badly in recent times at domestic level...he has the experience and still is live wire in the field...add to that a team man to core...basically every quality our current setup is carving for...but seems to have no takers...

what more he should do to be in the reckoning again unless selectors have completely forgotten him...he can be our ready made replacement of dravid type batsmen...at least in ODIs...

current system, on the look of it, somehow seems to favor the dashers and quietly but surely alienating itself from this genre?

the other day dhoni said that by giving these youngsters their chances now we will have crop of players by world cup who will have experience of 80-100 ODIs...would have gone through almost all situations game can throw at them and they will be knowing exactly what to expect from them and what is expected from them...

no problem with this vision...

but here is a guy who fits all these requirement to the 'T' and still spending his time in wilderness...

i know there were some faults in him as well...but who is perfect?...

don't you think the players like him should at least be given another chance to redeem themselves before its too late...given the feelers that they still belong to the system...the setup...

or more importantly...

do we really don't need players like Kaif??

it will be interesting to know your views...

click to translate »

a case for Dinesh Karthik...

shared by straight point on Saturday, December 15, 2007

this one is for SAM...i read his latest post on DK being larger than team...

i wanted to comment on this but my response got too much for space, so i have posted it out here...forgive me for wearing devil's advocate cap again ;-)

now look at what SAM says...

that it was DK's fifty who costed us victory in last test match...and he should be so ashamed that he should rule out himself of any future assignments with team india and better go to mollywood or bollywood... hummm....it got me thinking...

but, seriously even after thinking very long and hard i could not find a single reason...why DK should be ashamed of this...

he was not captaining india that day...so obviously it was not his decision to carry on batting...if kumble wanted that he wont bother for declaration and would go for full fifth day (we are not debating the rights or wrongs of declaration)...what DK, or for that matter any batsman, had anything to do with it...

you mean that he should have retired himself out from batting...put his hands up and said sorry captain i will not bat coz you are not declaring...common...SAM...would you have ashamed say SRT too if he was batting...??? he scored fifty coz he got the opportunity to play...as simple as that...

now other parts....why he is still in this team...i tried very hard to come up with reasons on this too...but could not come to term with it...that why he is in the team...then i found a way to crack this puzzle...for this we have to do it in reverse...like we used to do in school days to prove theorems...so lets start...why he is in team...

he must be a very BIG player...
seriously...why our captains (first dravid...then kumble), team managements and selectors can find a gut to drop out Ganguly's, Dravids...can keep sehwag out of team...can not find a place for YS in the team and yet we find DK in the team...coz he is as much a bigger player as cricket has seen...so he is untouchable...

he must be a HYPNOTIST
...he must have collectively brain washed everybody so much so that they can not see the obvious...

He has the backing of BIG CORPORATE HOUSES...
coz they have invested crores of rupees in him and if he is not selected in the team then they are going to loose BIG TIME...

he is the STAR...
people are falling over him like anything...they are queuing in daylight, sun blazing on their head...to see him play...he has cought the fancies of youngs and olds alike...has set up field blazing with his stroke play and all over world fans are going ga ga over him...

but on carefully examining all this i found that he is not a very big player...he is not a hypnotist either...yet to see a brand he endorses...and definitely not a star...so why he is in the team...

coz he is team man to the core...
coz he did the job in much tougher conditions when his more illustrious colleagues refused...
inspite of never opening in his career...
coz he is the most shuffled batsman in recent time for india...you want him open...he is ready...you want lower down to finish match...he is ready...who will come at no. 3??? he will...he will keep wickets...he will open for you...he is one of the best close in fielder and also good in deep down there with his agility that despite all in his career he has been keeper...

he averages at least a fifty (till this series) per test match...against much tougher teams...when team required it most...and its not that he is on his way to the fag end of his career...he is only 22 something...you wont find many players for which Harsha commenting (on record i.e.) that indian cricket got to find a way for some space for him...(during SA and/or england series)
and has this to say about DK in his recent column

"Now, people feel the need to react similarly about another fine and gutsy player. Since he began opening the innings, Dinesh Kaarthick has hardly ever failed. For a man not yet 23, he has been shunted all over the order and in the field, has faced more uncertainty than a stockbroker and has inevitably responded with good cheer and great attitude. He is not prone to making wild statements and, let’s face it, is performing a role that more pedigreed players were not too keen on. Openers have to be persevered with, you don’t throw a fresh lot in everytime, and that means riding the trough from time to time."

and i believe he has seen enough cricket to know the traits of a player...

the way he adjusted to the late inswing of sidebottom after getting out cheaply in first innings of first test match speaks about temperament, cricketing brain and the character of the man...that he is prepared to fight it out...showed he is always thinking about his game...that he is continuously looking to improve his game...

his true value lies elsewhere...he is a player from rare genre now...he is a TEAM MAN...its only that we are used of seeing so many stars out there that we don't don't give enough credit to this value...

yes he has spilled some easiest catches...yes he has shown some antics when he could have done it more calmly without showing off...yes he should have scored more runs against this weaker attack...but who has not...i have seen more specialist fielders spill dollies...Sehwag don't have good record against bangladesh...even SRT did not had good record against Bangladesh for a while...are they bad players...and surely you cannot drop a player for that he is a showman...

if anything he will learn with time, as i said he is only 20 something, when to show exuberance when to conceal expressions...etc..etc...

but can't we allow even this much to a guy so young...?? is it so difficult for us that we cant see the obvious through our tinted glasses of personal hate???

disclaimer: this post is not to score some brownie points over my friend SAM...

click to translate »

A Case for Yuvi & Sehwag

shared by straight point on Thursday, November 15, 2007

Before you start reading this blog...be warned of blogger's 'high handedness of english language'...though i wanted to start the blog much before but was bit apprehensive cause of reasons mentioned...i came thru a comment by soulberry somewhere that he has stopped reading Dilip's articles in CricInfo coz of so many grammar mistakes he makes or something of that sort...made me more nervous...

but comments from friends like homer and ottayam (forgive me for taking liberty of treating both of you as friends) has given me confidence to start it...so here i am daring to blog amongst the august company of well articulated, masters of language, definitely more knowledgeable guys blogging...

but i do hope that more than language i would be able to put across the message...so here i go...

----------

Although yuvi name does not arise so much of surprise as does sehwag's...for test team i.e.

For far too much time India is missing players who can crack the game open with their sheer talent and stroke play in Tests owing to various reasons not entirely of their control...

sehwag once considered second only to tendulkar was once even overshadowing him at one stage with his blistering strokes or else how many batsmen in world can boast of scoring almost double hundred in opening day of a test match down under!!

but with applause and media attention came some arrogance...some ignorance....towards the very game that brought him thus far...so we started to see different sehwag with heavy tyre around his waist...the once famous one liner 'the only difference between me and sachin is the bank balance' not turning up for practice sessions (as reported in media) not giving the post of vice captain of India the respect it deserves...and more importantly his own place in the team...and the most glaring aspects of these fact came in daylight for all world to see during SA series...

he was getting out in similar fashions during tests...one could say he always gets out in such ways...but difference to the past and then dismissals were that he was vice captain then...his dismissals had touch or arrogance and little respect to match and team situations... he kept on stroking balls same way as if to show to the world that there is nothing wrong in him and his form and that was sure recipe of disaster....

Same more or less with yuvi....although his case is more complex for not entirely of his fault though...he came in to test team with so much of anticipation...and started good with century against pakistan...and looked good for his future as well as team India...but then he was seen as threat to our reserved-for-life middle order of rd-sg-srt-lx...and there came the twist...as with sehwag's 'experimentation' of making him an opener...he was also 'guided' to become an opener so that the reservation policy of middle order is not breached...but he was not as lucky as sehwag coz he got confused....on how to approach his innings...

after sg's fiasco and his return to test team he got bit laid off thinking that now sg will not come back and taking things easy and thats where i think he faulted...

but now spending time in wilderness out of test teams (though yuvi has consolation of being regular in ODIs) they have come to know what it takes to be in the team...no amount of money...media adulation and 'difference in bank balance' can fulfill it...

thats why as Madan Lal says that there is purpose in Yuvi's batting these days he seems to have put his focus right up there and one can cleary see that its hearting him to no end to not to be in test team...that to not to be treated as good test match batsman that he is only respected for his ODI and more recently T20 flings...

and with sehwag...i still believes that he was and is not in the team not only for his performance only...and he too seems to learn his lessons the hard way...looking more fitter and eager and one can clearly feet the hurt thru his statements....
the way he was running between wickets in his only innings since his comeback (???) of 25 odd runs proves the point...

But people like sehwag and yuvraj can not be judged only by career stats coz their value lies elsewhere....coz when they will be on roll they will win you more matches then all other guys put together...they are what we call in modern cricket as 'game breakers' and their lies their true values...unless we want to play cricket like the era of b&w movies...as once the test cricket was played...

ask Australia who they want to see bat against them the jaffers, the SGs or Sehwag, Yuvraj (and Laxman too) and you will get the answer...

by not including them in test matches against pakistan we are depriving ourselves to see what they can do together in a team...and if we can not even pick them against pakistan now, who are hurting badly with the absence of asif and huffing-and-puffing akhtar, then i wonder when...

India is in the brink of the start of toughest season and what type of players you would like to see in team...the ones who are eager...got some points to prove to the world or the ones who even at the best of their day can only provide so much...

the choice is ours....and as they say we will be right either way if we think we can or we can not...

now start shooting....


click to translate »

about me...

BCC!straight point (sp) is restless... relentless... but a fun loving guy... likes to live life to fullest... trying to discover himself through cricket... welcome to this little world of his...

sp is also a bored member at BCC!

sp tweets

     


    © straight points
    straight points by sp is licensed under a creative commons attribution noncommercial-no derivative works 2.5 india license. based on a work at straightpoints.blogspot.com
    this blog takes no responsibility for statements posted by participants

    this blog is best viewed with Mozilla FireFox at a resolution of 1280 x 800 pixels
    thanks for the visit!!