the ball is in selectors court...

shared by straight point on Wednesday, January 27, 2010

before a ball is bowled in india vs south africa test series both camps seems to be in a bit of doldrums by some unexpected turn of events...

south africa will be without their regular coach mickey arthur... who authored his resignation just before the start of south africa's tour of india... though the air is still not clear about the exact reason of his resignation... but it is believed that arthur and graeme smith's working relations had reached a nadir and ultimately coach had to move out to make way...

the disturbances in india's camp are more direct that have the potential to impact final results... dravid, laxman and yuvraj injuries have coincided at the same time... and we are staring at the possibility of indian middle order without the likes of dravid and laxman for the first time since as far as my memory goes... though i expect laxman's injury will heal in time and he will be fit to play...

i deliberately not included yuvraj's name in the list of players team india will miss coz to me he has not done anything of note yet to convince me that he really belongs to the highest form of cricket... and even if he was not injured... i would have argued to drop him in first place for the upcoming series... who according to me is blocking a spot of a deserving player more than so called seniors...

what our five wise men failed to do for bangladesh test series... the unfortunate injuries have managed to do that against much tougher opponent... to try and mark some players who can play in middle order when the legends won't be there that is... goes to show even if you fail to show courage to take decisions the circumstances can force you to take them...

the series, in this light, will serve as 'preview' of what can happen when the vacuum will be created by mass exodus of legends if selectors fail to manage the transition...

so i hope and wish when our selectors will meet tomorrow (28th january) to select team india for the south africa test series... they will think out of box  and select the forgotten man of indian cricket... mohammad kaif... along with subramanium badrinath... and of course the steady murly vijay who seems to have become the 'instant fix' guy for team india of late will definitely get a place ...

its high time selector justify the central contract they have bestowed on badrinath for second successive time... and its high time we know whether badrinath has the game and temperament for highest level that can stand against tougher teams...

kaif has recently scored a double ton and a century in successive innings ... has international exposure and experience of almost all conditions and situations... is still a very good fielder... basically by all means another player who is an 'instant fix'...

so my team india batting order will be... sehwag, gambhir, vijay, sachin, kaif, laxman/badrinath, dhoni, with rohit sharma and/or dinesh karthik in reserves...

it will be interesting what middle order batting combination our five wise men will come up with tomorrow...


update:
the squad for the first test is announced... no sight of kaif even in board president xi... but badinath makes a comeback in team india... with saha and mithun being the fresh faces...

Team India: MS Dhoni (capt), Virender Sehwag, Gautam Gambhir, S Badrinath, Sachin Tendulkar, VVS Laxman, Harbhajan Singh, Zaheer Khan, Amit Mishra, Pragyan Ojha, Ishant Sharma, M Vijay, Sudeep Tyagi, Abhimanyu Mithun, Wriddhiman Saha.

Board President's XI: Abhinav Mukund, Parthiv Patel, Ajinkya Rahane, Rohit Sharma (capt), Manish Pandey, Cheteshwar Pujara, Abhishek Nayar, Piyush Chawla, R Ashwin, Vinay Kumar, Abhimanyu Mithun, Shikhar Dhawan, Umesh Yadav, Manpreet Gony.

24 comments:

Mahek said...

I see that even you have snubbed Che!

straight point said...

its not that i have snubbed che... i know for sure that they won't try out a new player... if you know what i mean... somehow che is way down their hierarchy level...

check this link about che... i have been following him since very beginning...

Mahek said...

It's a bit contradictory if you say you want them to pick Kaif by thinking outside the box and then say you're sure they won't try a new player. Picking Kaif is tantamount to them reaching inside the box for someone who's already been tried. Not that I have anything against Kaif, I always thought he should've been batting at number 3 in ODIs. But he's had his chances and I'd prefer someone who's been better than Kaif to finally get his chance.

straight point said...

nice catch mahek... :)

kaif's case is different... he was dumped without explanation... while pujara is yet to feature in any of their hierarchical order and talks...

going back to kaif will be accepting that they made a mistake in dumping him altogether that is why i asked them to think out of box which was parallel to out of comfort zone...

straight point said...

also if you have clicked on the link given in post where i argued for che's selection in bangladesh tour when tri series was being played...

if they cannot select him for bangla tour i doubt they will select him for sa series...

Mahek said...

I think he was dropped after just one hundred in six tests after Ganguly was dropped. Considering he played Sri Lanka, England and the West Indies on some good batting tracks I would say he didn't do enough to keep his place.

In any case, it was Ganguly who replaced him and the left-hander batted well enough to keep his place till he retired while Kaif struggled in first class cricket. He's had a good Ranji season this time but guys like Badrinath and Pujara have had multiple first class seasons in which they have scored big.

Mahek said...

I would agree with you on Che not being picked for the series against South Africa because he wasn't considered for the tour of Bangladesh. I'm hoping against hope that they'll give him a chance, although I wish the selection Gods smile on Badri first. There's another angle to this though. The selectors didn't pick ANY middle order batsman for Bangladesh. Vijay was the only backup and he's an opening batsman. Karthik was picked as a backup keeper who can bat in the middle order.

straight point said...

i think in that test series he was in good nick and he made fifty something in the last test too but he was dropped and forgotten like he never existed... kaif paid the price of final frontier being broken...

Megha said...

Isn't this a different selection committee to the one that dumped Kaif? If so, it wasn't their mistake anyway :)

Mahek said...

Eh? The 6 tests I'm talking about came after the final frontier was breached, after Pakistan came to India and drew the series. If anything, Kaif got his chance because the results of those two home series didn't go India's way and people finally realised Ganguly wasn't pulling his weight.

Megha

That selection committee was worse than the one that followed. The successors picked Wasim "I deserve more than $100,000 in the IPL" Jaffer for the ODI series in South Africa.

straight point said...

megha... yes though the selection committee was different but i find mind-set the same... :)

straight point said...

all in all i don't know when was the last time i was so eager and excited for test series selections...

Mahek said...

Don't get your hopes up, SP. They'll end up picking Nohit :P

Som said...

SP, I'm glad someone noticed Kaif. Since it would be a battle of world's top two teams, I don't think India would tinker a lot. But Murali Vijay needs to be backed and Badrinath deserves a place in playing XI. We have done our bit to convince Badri that he doesn't belong. Time to make amends.

straight point said...

infact som we have done our bit to convince both kaif and badri that they does not belong...

as i said its been a time since i was looking to team selection with this anticipation... i hope selectors will realise that they are on the verge of historic selection... that can shape the future of team india...

Trideep said...

SP.. I dont think our selectors will give a totally new player any chance. Thts not how our selectors think. Infact i think they will go with some tried and tested players.. even if that means picking players who have been successful in ODI's and T20's..

Trideep said...

just to add... my new link

http://crickosphere.blogspot.com/

Soulberry said...

Makes sense and could happen the way you suggest SP, but I feel somehow Rohit Sharma will be made a test batsman like Yuvraj. He is the dark horse for selection according to me.

Another man who will be plunged in is Kohli perhaps.

That leaves one spot for Badri, Vijay, Kaif and Raina to fight for.

I am wondering if Cheeka will play boh Badri and Vijay.

straight point said...

spot on trideep... i expect them to do the same way... tho i am not averse to pleasant surprises as well... :)

and thanks for the link i will update the blogroll...

straight point said...

thanks sb!

rohit indeed is dark horse in all sense... i still believe if he can tighten up on temperament front he will make a good test bat...

but as far as final xi goes i still don't see him breaking into it... while badri, kaif alongwith murli makes a good combination...

lets see... *finger crossed*

Mahek said...

Nohit is a langda ghoda, not a dark horse.

straight point said...

the dark horse is made captain of bp-xi... which means, what matters in end, selectors indeed see him as lambi race ka ghoda... :)

Soulberry said...

Well, only Badri is in while Karthik is dropped for Saha. Saha needs to be expoed but did DK deserve a kick?

Bowler for bowler and Laxman is playing.

straight point said...

sb... i think even selectors are giving up on dk...

he blew the opportunity he got in bangla... and more than the runs he did not make... he never looked in control while batting...

its better to look for new avenues than and saha is the one they have zeroed in... :)

about me...

BCC!straight point (sp) is restless... relentless... but a fun loving guy... likes to live life to fullest... trying to discover himself through cricket... welcome to this little world of his...

sp is also a bored member at BCC!

sp tweets

     


    © straight points
    straight points by sp is licensed under a creative commons attribution noncommercial-no derivative works 2.5 india license. based on a work at straightpoints.blogspot.com
    this blog takes no responsibility for statements posted by participants

    this blog is best viewed with Mozilla FireFox at a resolution of 1280 x 800 pixels
    thanks for the visit!!